The differences between Pittsfield, Lenox, and Stockbridge may grab our attention first, but look again, we have a lot in common. For example, we are all grappling with how to protect our historic buildings.
In Pittsfield, the Pittsfield Historic Commission tried to save the Catholic Youth Center Building by using the Demolition Delay Bylaw. The purpose of a Demolition Delay Bylaw is to pause development for a year during which the building cannot be demolished and a new buyer who wishes to preserve it might be found. There was a willing buyer, but the owners did not wish to sell. They wished to demolish the old and construct another building on the spot just as the owners of Spring Lawn wish to do in Lenox. That is how Pittsfield lost another historic building
This year, in Lenox, they celebrated the fiftieth anniversary of the Lenox Historical Commission (LHC). In addition, Lenox has an historic district, a Demolition Delay Bylaw, and a specific bylaw to protect the great estates. Lenox has layers of protection because Town residents value the buildings and understand their role in Lenox economics. And yet, the village waits on tenterhooks to discover the fate of Spring Lawn, an architecturally and historically significant Berkshire Cottage.
In May 2025, Stockbridge granted a permit to develop 35-37 Interlaken Road (DeSisto School). At a Conservation Commission (ConCom) meeting in October 2026, a representative for DeSisto submitted a plan that appeared different from the plan approved by the Permitting Authority. In addition, the developer asked ConCom to relieve them of the requirement for a stormwater permit. In Massachusetts, the purpose of stormwater permits is to protect waterways and safeguard public health. They are granted by federal, state and local agencies and rarely exempted. Permitted plans can be changed, however, if substantive, the changes must be reviewed and approved by the Permitting Authority. In Stockbridge, the Permitting Authority is the Select Board, not ConCom.
In all three municipalities: there is deterioration of buildings from neglect. In some cases, neglect is followed by a request to demolish the building because it is now unsafe or beyond repair. Preservationists suspect that in some cases, neglect is purposeful to justify demolition.
Are the examples above strategies to circumvent zoning bylaws? In Pittsfield, outwait the demolition delay bylaw; in Lenox, venue shop on any governmental level: bypass the appropriate, local authority, Lenox Historical Commission and go to Mass Historical Commission; in Stockbridge, rewrite the permit and hope ConCom doesn’t notice and have an argument and have a lawyer ready if they do. If these are strategies, what tools do municipalities have to compel property maintenance and compliance with bylaws? Should municipalities pass a law to compel property maintenance or are there already such bylaws in place? Is there a mechanism to dissuade noncompliance by attaching fines? In Massachusetts, there is a requirement that if the owner of property having a Conservation Restriction (CR) requests that the CR to be removed, the municipality has an automatic right of first refusal. Does Lenox have a right of first refusal on Spring Lawn if and when the CR is removed? Can that requirement about a right of first refusal be expanded, for example, if the property has a value to the municipality itself? Can eminent domain be used when a building has deteriorated to a certain point but before demolition is permitted?
By citing these examples, we have not found a solution; we only have defined the problem. There is a connection between historic buildings and the character of a town, its economic base, and the love its residents feel. For those who understand that, take the next step.

